A Values-Based Analysis of Recovery-Oriented Practice in Mental Health Care and Medical Assistance in Dying
Publication: Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health
28 August 2020
Abstract
The Criminal Code of Canada has been amended to allow medical assistance in dying (MAiD) under prescribed criteria. There has been considerable debate regarding whether people with mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition should be eligible. It is argued that access to MAiD is not compatible with recovery-oriented care. Based on a comprehensive analysis exploring the ethical principles guiding decision making around MAiD, this paper offers a discussion of the compatibility between MAiD and recovery-oriented care and demonstrates significant overlap of these principles. The discussion around MAiD as an option in recovery-oriented care is legitimate and needs to continue.
Résumé
Le Code criminel du Canada a été amendé pour autoriser l’assistance médicale à mourir (AMM) selon certains critères. Nombre de débats ont eu lieu quant à savoir si les personnes atteintes uniquement de maladie mentale pouvaient être considérées comme éligibles à l’AMM. L’incompatibilité de l’AMM avec les soins axés sur le rétablissement fait l’objet de nombreuses discussions. Fondé sur une analyse exhaustive des principes éthiques guidant la prise de décision autour de l’AMM, cet article propose une discussion sur la compatibilité entre l’AMM et les soins axés sur le rétablissement tout en démontrant un chevauchement important entre les deux. Le débat autour de l’AMM comme une option parmi les soins axés sur le rétablissement est légitime et se doit d’être poursuivit.
Formats available
You can view the full content in the following formats:
REFERENCES
Berghmans R., Widdershoven G., and Widdershoven-Heerding I. 2013 Physician-assisted suicide in psychiatry and loss of hope International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 36 5 436 -443
Blikshavn T., Husum T. L., and Magelssen M. 2017 Four reasons why assisted dying should not be offered for depression Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 14 1 151 -157
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health. (2017). Medical assistance in dying (MAiD) and Mental Health (Full). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rsNQomwa8WE
Charland L. C., Lemmens T., and Wada K. 2016 Decision-making capacity to consent to medical assistance in dying for persons with mental disorders Journal of Ethics in Mental Health, Open Volume Retrieved from https://jemh.ca
Coyle N. and Sculco L. 2004 Expressed desire for hastened death in seven patients living with advanced cancer: A phenomenologic inquiry Oncology Nursing Forum 31 4 699 -709
Dembo J., Schuklenk U., and Reggler J. 2018 “For Their Own Good”: A response to popular arguments against permitting medical assistance in dying (MAID) where mental illness is the sole underlying condition Canadian Journal of Psychiatry Revue Canadienne de Psychiatrie 63 7 451 -456
Doernberg S. N., Peteet J. R., and Kim S. Y. 2016 Capacity evaluations of psychiatric patients requesting assisted death in the Netherlands Psychosomatics 57 6 556 -565
Downie J. and Dembo J. 2016 Medical assistance in dying and mental illness under the new Canadian law Journal of Ethics in Mental Health, Open Volume Retrieved from https://jemh.ca
Incardona, N., Bean, S., Reel, K., & Wagner, F. (2016). An ethics-based analysis and recommendations for implementing physician-assisted dying in Canada. Toronto: Joint Centre for Bioethics, University of Toronto.
Kim S. Y. and Lemmens T. 2016 Should assisted dying for psychiatric disorders be legalized in Canada? Canadian Medical Association Journal
Le Boutillier C., Leamy M., Bird V. J., Davidson L., Williams J., and Slade M. 2011 What does recovery mean in practice? A qualitative analysis of international recovery-oriented practice guidance Psychiatric Services 62 12 1470 -1476
Leamy M., Bird V., Le Boutillier C., Williams J., and Slade M. 2011 Conceptual framework for personal recovery in mental health: Systematic review and narrative synthesis The British Journal of Psychiatry 199 6 445 -452
Lemmens, T. (2016). The conflict between open-ended access to physician-assisted dying and the protection of the vulnerable: Lessons from Belgium’s euthanasia regime for the Canadian post-Carter era. In C. Regis, L. Khoury & R. Kouri, (Eds.), Les Grands Conflits en Droit de la Santé [Key Conflicts in Health Law], (pp. 261–317). Cowensville: Yvon Blais.
Maher J. 2017 What troubles me as a psychiatrist about the physician assisted suicide debate in Canada Journal of Ethics in Mental Health, Open Volume 10 1 -5
McCormack B., Borg M., Cardiff S., Dewing J., Jacobs G., Titchen A., van Lieshout F., and Wilson V. 2016 A kaleidoscope of hope: Exploring experiences of hope among service users and informal careers in health care contexts Journal of Holistic Nursing
Mental Health Commission of Canada. (2015). Guidelines for Recovery-Oriented Practice. Ottawa, ON.
Rooney W., Schuklenk U., and van de Vathorst S. 2017 Are concerns about irremediableness, vulnerability, or competence sufficient to justify excluding all psychiatric patients from medical aid in dying? Health Care Analysis 1 -18
Schrank B., Stanghellini G., and Slade M. 2008 Hope in psychiatry: A review of the literature Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 118 6 421 -433
Shaffer C. S., Cook A. N., and Connolly D. A. 2016 A conceptual framework for thinking about physician-assisted death for persons with a mental disorder Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 22 2 141
Sheehan K., Gaind K. S., and Downar J. 2017 Medical assistance in dying: Special issues for patients with mental illness Current Opinion in Psychiatry 30 1 26 -30
Shepherd, G., Boardman, J., & Slade, M. (2008). Making recovery a reality. London, UK: Sainsbury Centre for Mental Health.
Slade M. 2012 Everyday solutions for everyday problems: How mental health systems can support recovery Psychiatric Services 63 7 702 -704
Starson v. Swayze, Court of Appeal for Ontario, 2003.
The Economist. (2015). 24 and ready to die. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWWkUzkfJ4M
Thienpont L., Verhofstadt M., Van Loon T., Distelmans W., Audenaert K., and De Deyn P. P. 2015 Euthanasia requests, procedures and outcomes for 100 Belgian patients suffering from psychiatric disorders: A retrospective, descriptive study British Medical Journal Open 5 7 e007454
Truchon v. Procureur Général Du Canada, Superior Court of Québec, 2019.
Walker-Renshaw B. and Finley M. 2016 Will the SCC’s decision on physician-assisted death apply to persons suffering from severe mental illness? Health Law in Canada 36 3 74 -79
Whitley R. 2010 Rediscovering hope Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal 33 3 239
Young J. S., Cashwell C. S., and Woolington V. J. 1998 The relationship of spirituality to cognitive and moral development and purpose in life: An exploratory investigation Counseling and Values 43 1 63 -69
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health
Volume 39 • Number 2 • July 2020
Pages: 1 - 10
History
Version of record online: 28 August 2020
Key Words
Mots-clés
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Other Metrics
Citations
Cite As
Rosanna Macri, Frank Wagner, and Melanie I. Stuckey. 2020. A Values-Based Analysis of Recovery-Oriented Practice in Mental Health Care and Medical Assistance in Dying. Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health.
39(2): 1-10. https://doi.org/10.7870/cjcmh-2020-009
Export Citations
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
There are no citations for this item
View Options
View options
Login options
Check if you access through your login credentials or your institution to get full access on this article.
Subscribe
Click on the button below to subscribe to Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health
